The Ultimate Fire Island Travel Guide
photo: Nik Knoppova
Fire Island is a stunning island located off the coast of Long Island, New York. It is famous for its breathtaking beaches, vibrant LGBTQ+ community, and friendly atmosphere.
What made the experience amazing was the happiness that surrounded everyone, and there was no judgment for who you were. It was truly a paradise.
I fell in love with Fire Island the first time I visited it a few years ago with my roommates. Now it has become one of my favorite places to go swimming and relax. I make sure to visit Fire Island at least once a year, especially when the warm weather starts creeping in in New York.
｡˚⋆❀🍹⛵🐚𓇼 ˖°｡
Fire Island’s history
Fire Island has a long and interesting history. Originally named Whaling Island, it was a hub for whaling goods and the first permanent resident was Jeremiah Smith, a notorious land pirate.
The Fire Island Lighthouse served as a landmark for transatlantic ships and still stands as both a landmark and a museum.
In the 1950s, real estate boomed and the island became a popular destination for visitors. Today, visitors can enjoy fishing, sailing, swimming, and hiking while learning about the island's fascinating history.
｡˚⋆❀🍹⛵🐚𓇼 ˖°｡
know before you go!
LANGUAGE
English is the primary language
TIME ZONE
Fire Island operates on Eastern Daylight Time (EDT).
BEST TIME TO VISIT
Fire Island truly comes alive during the summer months (June - August), offering the best weather for enjoying the beaches and outdoor activities. However, my favorite time to visit would be in the fall! (September)
CURRENCY
The U.S. dollar (USD) is the official currency. While some establishments have adopted credit card readers, cash is still widely preferred, especially during peak season (Memorial Day weekend, summer months). ATMs are available on the island, but it's wise to bring some cash beforehand to avoid potential withdrawal fees.
TIPPING
A 15-20% tip is customary for good service at restaurants.
CELL SERVICE
Cell service can be spotty on certain parts of the island. It's a good idea to download maps and any information you might need beforehand in case you lose reception.
SAFETY
Fire Island is known for its relaxed and safe atmosphere. However, general precautions like keeping an eye on your belongings and being mindful of your surroundings are always recommended, especially in crowded areas.
SUSTAINABLE PRACTICES
Fire Island is a treasured natural environment. Be a responsible visitor by practicing Leave No Trace principles, packing out all trash, and respecting the delicate ecosystem.
｡˚⋆❀🍹⛵🐚𓇼 ˖°｡
what to bring
BEACH ESSENTIALS
- Swimwear
- Towels
- Sunscreen & Hat
- Sunglasses
ISLAND ACTIVITIES
- Reusable Water Bottle: Stay hydrated throughout your day with a reusable water bottle. Water fountains are readily available for refilling.
- Snacks
- Change of Clothes
OPTIONAL
- Portable Charger
- Portable Speaker (with caution): Check with your chosen community about noise restrictions before packing a portable speaker.
- Mosquito Spray: This can be helpful if you plan on venturing beyond the main beaches, especially near the Sunken Forest. However, some areas may be actively managed for mosquitos, so check local conditions before packing.
- Cash
｡˚⋆❀🍹⛵🐚𓇼 ˖°｡
getting there
Since Fire Island is known for not having cars around the island — yes, no cars — getting to Fire Island can be a bit of a challenge, but the journey is definitely worth it once you’re there!
Traveling from NYC 🗽
TRAIN » FERRY
This is a popular and convenient choice. Take the subway to Penn Station and transfer to the Long Island Railroad (LIRR) heading to Bay Shore, Sayville, or Patchogue. These stations connect directly to ferry terminals.
BUS » FERRY
The Bay Bus offers a direct route to the Sayville Ferry terminal. This is a good option if you prefer a single transfer or don't want to navigate the subway system.
RIDE SHARE » FERRY
No car? No problem! Use Uber or Lyft to get to the nearest ferry terminal convenient for your chosen departure point. Then, simply purchase your ferry ticket!
CAR » FERRY
If you have a car, you can drive to various ferry locations:
- Take the ferry from Bay Shore, Sayville, or Patchogue, where you can park your car at a designated lot and then hop on the ferry.
- Drive to Robert Moses State Park and park your car with a daily fee. From there, you can access Fire Island via water taxi, bike, or walk (depending on your destination).
💡 TIP
While the ferries typically accept cash, you can skip the line and go contactless!
Download the "FI mTickets" app to purchase your ferry tickets conveniently and avoid trying to find cash when you arrive. You can also use your FI mTickets app to request water taxi rides!
Traveling from Out of State
FLY » TRAIN
Most major airlines fly into John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK), LaGuardia Airport (LGA), or Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR). From your chosen airport, take a taxi or rideshare service (like Uber or Lyft) to Penn Station in Manhattan.
TRAIN » FERRY
At Penn Station, hop on the Long Island Railroad (LIRR) heading to Bay Shore, Sayville, or Patchogue. These stations connect directly to ferry terminals.
｡˚⋆❀🍹⛵🐚𓇼 ˖°｡
what to do
Fire Island
Bucket List
Check it off! — If you want to make the most of your trip, I gotchu! You'll find all the best spots to explore, fun water activities, delicious seafood to try, and fascinating history to learn about!
｡˚⋆❀🍹⛵🐚𓇼 ˖°｡
where to explore
There are endless activities to enjoy on Fire Island, such as hiking, birdwatching, beachcombing, swimming, kayaking, and visiting local landmarks. Some of the top attractions that I recommend and we went to are:
explore Cherry Grove
This vibrant community is known for its LGBTQ+ scene and is home to many restaurants, bars, and shops.
Cherry Grove felt alive and the place to be at.
You can see many beautiful places and walk to the beach if you’re feeling too hot.
The Sunken Forest
This unique maritime ecosystem of stunted oak trees is a must-see attraction on the island and is at Sailors Haven.
Make sure to wear a TON of mosquito spray before entering if you easily get bit by mosquitoes!
Thank you to my girl, Nik for recommending us to explore the Sunken Forest!
｡˚⋆❀🍹⛵🐚𓇼 ˖°｡
check out my Culebra travel vlog!
｡˚⋆❀🍹⛵🐚𓇼 ˖°｡
SUGGESTED FOR YOU
Last Updated: 05.23.2024
Sink your toes into its powdery white sands and watch the gnarly waves splash onto the shore as you lay in the sun ☀️